Processing math: 100%

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Problem 1

MathJax TeX Test Page 1. Do there exist irrational numbers r,s such that rs is rational? Do there exist irrational numbers r,s such that rs is irrational?

Really, Wikipedia ruined this problem for me in advance, or at least part a. The answer to both these problems is yes.

Proof: (a) The easiest methods are nonconstructive; observe α=22. Either α is rational, in which the proposition is established, or α is irrational. If α is irrational, then α2=2(2·2)=22=2 is a pair of irrationals α,2 establishing the proposition.

(b) My method for this too is nonconstructive; assume the proposition is false. Then observe the map 2_:. Since the union of two countable sets would then be countable, and since is uncountable, we have is uncountable. Therefore this map is not injective and we have 2r=2r for some distinct irrationals r,r. But exponentiation is naturally injective, so we observe a contradiction.

No comments:

Post a Comment