Processing math: 100%

Tuesday, April 22, 2014

Infinitude of Primitive Solutions for x^3+y^3=7z^3 (15.1.45)

MathJax TeX Test Page Let V=Z(x3+y3+7z3)3. Then I(V)=(x3+y3+7z3)[x,y,z] (cf. 15.3.24).
(a) Show that Φ(x)=x(y37z3),     Φ(y)=y(7z3x3),     Φ(z)=z(x3y3) defines a -algebra homomorphism from k[V] to itself.
(b) Let φ : VV be the morphism corresponding to Φ. Observe that (2,1,1)V and compute φ(2,1,1).
(c) Prove that there are infinitely many points (a,b,c)V with a,b,c and the greatest common divisor of a,b,c is 1.

Proof: (a) It sufficies to show Φ(x3+y3+7z3)(x3+y3+7z3), and indeed general polynomial division will reveal x3+y3+7z3 | Φ(x3+y3+7z3).

(b) We see φ is the morphism defined by φ(a,b,c)=(a(b37c3),b(7c3a3),c(a3b3)), so φ(2,1,1)=(12,15,9).

(c) We may assume a,b,c for (a,b,c)V are pairwise relatively prime when a,b,c have a trivial greatest common factor; to see this, assume two elements are divisible by a prime p. By reducing x3+y3+7z3=0 modulo p3, we see that the other element too must be divisible by p, impossible if they have trivial greatest common factor.

Let ψ(a,b,c)=φ(a,b,c)d when d is the greatest common factor of the three coordinates of φ(a,b,c). We shall show the first coordinate of (a,b,c) is smaller than or equal in absolute value than that of the first coordinate of Ψ(a,b,c) as well as are the second coordinates when c0, but that they cannot both be equalities, so Ψi(2,1,1)Ψj(2,1,1) for nonnegative ij.

Assume an arbitrary prime p | d when d is the greatest common divisor of the coordinates of φ(a,b,c)=(a(b37c3),b(7c3a3),c(a3b3)) when (a,b,c)V. We have p | a or p | (b37c3); assume the former. Then since (a,b)=1 we have p | (7c3a3). Reduce modulo p to observe either p=7 or p | c, only the former being possible. But now reduce a3+b3+7c3=0 modulo p=7 to still get p | b. Hence p| a. Since p was arbitrary this implies d | (b37c3), so a | a when a is the first coordinate of Ψ(a,b,c). This shows |a||a|, and by very similar reasoning |b||b|.

The only possible case for |a|=|a| and |b|=|b| implies |d|=|b37c3|=|7c3a3|. But either b37c3=7c3a3 or b37c3=a37c3 together with the hypothesis a3+b3+7c3=0 implies c=0, a contradiction. Therefore the absolute inequality is strict and the proposition is established. 

No comments:

Post a Comment